How Should Claimed Murder Experience Be Verified?
A lawyer says they’ve tried murder cases. Here’s how to check.
By Heath Hyde · Heath Hyde, P.C. · East Texas and statewide
Mr. Heath Enix ‘Heath’ Hyde
Eligible to Practice in Texas
Attorney at Law
Bar Card Number: 00796807
TX License Date: 11/01/1996
Primary Practice Location: Dallas, Texas
Return to the Texas Murder Trial Defense Knowledge Hub
Short answer
Public records can show that a lawyer is licensed, board certified, and listed in a real case. They can’t show everything the lawyer did at that trial. So you turn each claim into a county, a year, and a role, then look it up.
| What the lawyer may say | What to ask for |
|---|---|
| “I’ve tried murder cases.” | First chair, second chair, or prosecution? |
| “I’ve done hundreds of homicides.” | How many you tried, not just handled |
| “Our firm has a long record.” | Which cases you handled personally |
| “I won that case.” | Acquittal, lesser verdict, dismissal, or plea? |
What to do now: Ask the lawyer for one cause number you can look up this week.
What exactly is the lawyer claiming?
At a first meeting, a lawyer may lean back in a leather chair and say, “I’ve tried a dozen of these.” That might mean twelve murder trials as lead counsel. It might also mean twelve felony trials of any kind, some as a prosecutor and some as second chair.
For every vague line, get:
- the county
- the year
- the lawyer’s role
- for “I won,” whether an appeal changed the result
A useful entry on your list reads: a district court in an East Texas county, a 2019 murder jury trial, the lawyer led the defense through both phases, and the jury convicted on a lesser offense. Every part of that entry can be checked.
Which public source answers which question?
Each source answers a different question, so you’ll likely use all three.
| Source | What it can and can’t confirm |
|---|---|
| State Bar of Texas profile | License and public discipline, but no trial list |
| Texas Board of Legal Specialization | Board certification and area, but no trial |
| County court records | The case and counsel, but not who questioned whom |
The State Bar’s Find-a-Lawyer directory has a profile for every licensed Texas attorney. Check that the name and bar card number match. Check that the lawyer is eligible to practice, because a lawyer who isn’t eligible can’t represent anyone.
According to the State Bar’s guide on selecting a lawyer, the directory lists public disciplinary actions. Practice areas on a profile are self-reported, though.
What to do now: Save a copy of each profile page, with the date you viewed it.
How do you check a board certification claim?
Say the lawyer’s card reads “Board Certified” under the name. Search the Texas Board of Legal Specialization’s site at tbls.org.
Under Rule 7.02(b)(1) of the disciplinary rules, a lawyer may advertise “Board Certified” in an area only if TBLS has certified them in that area.
Certification is area-specific, so check that the listed area matches what the lawyer told you. Certification is a credential, not a trial record. It doesn’t show that the lawyer led any particular murder trial.
Write the area and the date you searched next to the lawyer’s name. If the search shows nothing, bring the business card to the next meeting and ask what “Board Certified” on it refers to.
How do you check a case in county court records?
Say the lawyer names a 2019 trial in a county two hours away and gives you the defendant’s name. Court case records are generally kept by the clerk of the court. Felony cases are filed in district court, so the district clerk there is your first call.
Ask the clerk how to search criminal case records and what copies cost. Search by the defendant’s name, or by the cause number if the lawyer can give it. The docket sheet lists filings and settings.
The judgment shows how the case ended and may name the attorneys who appeared. A trial transcript is the record that shows who questioned each witness, so ask whether one exists.
Say the clerk finds Cause No. 19-0412 on a docket sheet. The judgment on page 3 lists two defense lawyers, and the one you met is second. You ask her at the next meeting who handled cross-examination of the State’s key witness.
The Texas Judicial Branch explains that access to court case records is governed by common law, statutes, and court rules. Some records may be sealed or confidential.
| If the record shows | What to do next |
|---|---|
| Nothing online | Ask the clerk; not every county posts records. |
| A different lawyer | Ask what this lawyer did in that case. |
| A sealed file | Ask for a different case you can check. |
| This lawyer on the judgment | Ask which witnesses the lawyer examined. |

What can’t a lawyer tell you about past cases?
Say you ask about the 2019 trial, and the lawyer says, “I can’t talk about that client.” Some limits are real, and some aren’t.
| Limit | How it works |
|---|---|
| Client confidentiality | Rule 1.05 protects client information, so private details may stay private. |
| Public record | Filings, judgments, and open-court appearances are generally public. |
| Misleading claims | Rule 7.01(a): statements likely to create unjustified expectations about results are misleading. |
So the lawyer may decline to tell you what the client said in the jail interview room. The lawyer can still give you the cause number, the county, and the date the jury came back. A lawyer can usually point you to the public record without revealing confidences.
What can a family do to check a lawyer’s record?
Maybe your sister has a free afternoon and a phone with a good signal. Maybe the lawyer you liked best gave you three case names on a sticky note.
Build a short file for each lawyer:
- A dated copy of the State Bar profile
- The TBLS search result
- Each cause number and county the lawyer gave
- The clerk’s docket sheet or judgment for each case
Take the file to the next meeting and go through it line by line.
Frequently asked questions
Is a website’s “case results” page proof of experience?
A line reading “Not guilty, Smith County” is a lead. Get the year and the cause number, then pull the judgment.
Does a long career mean murder trial experience?
Twenty years in practice could be mostly pleas, or mostly civil work. Ask for the trials, by county and year.
Do a former prosecutor’s murder trials count?
They count as trial experience. The job differs from defense work, though, so ask which defense trials the lawyer has also led.
What if the lawyer won’t name any case?
Ask why. A lawyer can usually point to some public record without revealing confidences.
Talk with Heath Hyde
You can check Heath Hyde’s State Bar of Texas profile the same way. Call Heath Hyde, P.C. at 903.439.0000 or request a free consultation.
Legal sources
- State Bar of Texas, Find a Lawyer
- Texas Board of Legal Specialization
- Texas Judicial Branch, Open Records Policy
This article provides general educational information, not legal advice. Every case depends on its facts, evidence, court, deadlines and governing law. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.



