How Can a Family Preserve Evidence Without Interfering With Witnesses?
Keep the phone. Keep the receipts. Leave the witnesses to the lawyer.
By Heath Hyde · Heath Hyde, P.C. · East Texas and statewide
Mr. Heath Enix ‘Heath’ Hyde
Eligible to Practice in Texas
Attorney at Law
Bar Card Number: 00796807
TX License Date: 11/01/1996
Primary Practice Location: Dallas, Texas
Return to the Texas Murder Trial Defense Knowledge Hub
Short answer
A family can keep a phone, a receipt, or a doorbell clip exactly as it is. It can’t call witnesses to compare stories or offer anyone anything for what they say. So you write down where each item came from and hand the lawyer names instead of making calls.
| What a family may want to do | What to do instead |
|---|---|
| Scroll through his phone and clean it up | Leave it untouched and note who has held it. |
| Print the texts and toss the phone | Keep both the printout and the phone. |
| Call the neighbor to “check her story” | Give the lawyer her name and number. |
| Log into a witness’s account | Don’t. Tell the lawyer what you saw. |
What to do now: Call the lawyer today about any camera footage. Home systems record over old video on a schedule, and the lawyer needs to know that schedule.
What should a family write down and keep?
Before anyone scrolls through your brother’s phone, get a sheet of paper. The lawyer will have to show where each item came from, and the sheet starts that record.
| Item | One line on the sheet |
|---|---|
| His phone | Owner, everyone who held it since Saturday, anything deleted |
| A neighbor’s doorbell camera | Address, owner’s name, when it records over |
| Screenshots someone sent you | Who sent them, and when |
| Receipts, work schedules, gas slips | Where you found each one |
| A social media post | The link and the date you saw it |
Two cautions:
- Receipts and gas station slips stay in the paper they came in. They can matter for an alibi.
- A post about the case gets a dated screenshot and no reply.
Does a copy count, or do we need the original?
Rule 1001(d) treats an accurate printout of phone data as an “original.” The phone still matters, because a printout holds only what someone chose to print.
| Rule | What it says |
|---|---|
| TRE 901(a) | The offering side must show an item is what it claims. |
| TRE 1001(d) | An accurate printout of electronic data counts as an “original.” |
| TRE 1002 | An original is generally required to prove content. |
| TRE 1003 | A duplicate comes in like the original, unless authenticity is questioned or it’s unfair. |
Your notes on where an item came from help the lawyer meet Rule 901. A screenshot can leave out messages, dates, or senders. That’s why the full thread on the original device still matters.
Say your sister screenshots 14 messages from a 220-message thread and sends them to the lawyer. The thread’s message at 11:52 p.m., the one that explains the rest, isn’t in her set. The lawyer asks for the phone itself.
Can we get into someone’s phone or account to save messages?
Only if you already have permission to use it. Texas Penal Code §33.02(a) makes it an offense to knowingly access a computer or system without the owner’s effective consent.
Say a cousin guesses the password to the accused’s email and downloads messages. That’s the access problem §33.02(a) covers. A sister who logs into a witness’s social media to screenshot posts has the same problem, and she’s now in direct contact with a witness’s private data.
A parent who pays for the family phone plan may want the call logs. Whether that access is allowed depends on the facts, so ask the lawyer first.
Is it a crime to talk to a witness?
An uncle runs into a neighbor at the gas station and says, “You didn’t really see him that night, right?” Contact alone isn’t the offense. But a line like that can look like an attempt to change testimony, and in a murder case the penalty is severe.
| Statute | What it covers |
|---|---|
| Penal Code §36.05(a) | A benefit or coercion to influence a witness’s testimony or attendance |
| Penal Code §36.05(d) | Tampering in a murder case is a first-degree felony. |
| Penal Code §36.06 | Harming or threatening someone because they’re a witness |
| Penal Code §37.09(a)(1), (d)(1) | Altering or hiding evidence, before or during an investigation |
Section 36.05(a) covers intent to make a witness lie, hold back evidence, avoid a subpoena, skip court, or drop a prosecution. Under §36.05(d), tampering is the same level of offense as the most serious charge.

What else can go wrong after the arrest?
Bond can add rules of its own. Art. 17.40 lets a magistrate set conditions to protect a victim or the community, and breaking one can cost the bond.
Paying a witness’s rent
A friend offers to cover a witness’s rent “to help her out.” If the money is meant to influence what she says, §36.05(a) covers it.
Deleting a group chat
Two days after the arrest, at 2 a.m., his girlfriend taps “delete for everyone” on a nine-person chat. The other eight phones may still hold the thread, and now the State may have a story about a cover-up.
Texting someone the bond order names
A no-contact condition doesn’t care that the message was kind. “How are you holding up?” can still break it.
What can a family do when witness information comes in?
Maybe a coworker stops your mother in the church parking lot and says she saw something that night. Maybe a rumor about another possible suspect is all over the neighborhood by Sunday.
Pass these to the lawyer, in a private meeting or call:
- Names and phone numbers of people who may know something
- Notes on what anyone volunteered, with the date and place
- The source of each rumor you heard
- A record of any witness who called the family
Don’t ask follow-up questions or call anyone back. If a witness wants to talk, say the lawyer’s office will reach out, and let the investigator do the checking.
Frequently asked questions
Can I give the lawyer the accused’s phone?
Call first. How the phone is handed over and stored can matter later.
Should we post on social media asking for witnesses?
A post asking “who saw something on Elm Street Saturday night?” can reach a witness the State already interviewed, and the post itself becomes a record. Let the defense investigator look for witnesses.
Do our notes have to be perfect?
Write what you know and mark what you’re unsure of. Don’t change notes after the fact.
Talk with Heath Hyde
Bring the list of what your family has kept. Call Heath Hyde, P.C. at 903.439.0000 or request a free consultation.
Legal sources
This article provides general educational information, not legal advice. Every case depends on its facts, evidence, court, deadlines and governing law. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.



